💡 Trivia Pastor Boy Dila, Pinanalo ng Comelec

MANILA, Philippines — The Commission on Elections Second Division has declared Benny Abante as the duly elected Representative of the Manila City 6th District in the 2025 midterm elections.

This came after the division voided the certificate of candidacy of Joel Uy, whose proclamation is considered “annùlléd.”

Source: You do not have permission to view the full content of this post. Log in or register now.

 

[plhbg1]

But that doesn't change the fact that he only gets stray votes.

haha naging stray nga lang yan dahil sa disqualification, same lang din yan na naging winner lang dahil sa disqualification, hindi yan stray from the start, tingnan na lang natin ang result ng appeal since reversible pa yan, nothing is final yet

 

[adcaurienll]

obvious naman na may under the tables transactions nangyari jan, puro leaning sa mga duterte ang ponterya, di na ako magtataka kung 2026 biglang mag martial law, o revolutionary government bigla kesyo may gyera na or kon ano idadahilan, ou its a stretch pero bantayan nyo na, napakarumi ng galaw ng nga may poder ngayon, akala mo habang buha sila nasa taas, may araw din kayo.

 

[BicycleHorse]

Matagal na sa Pulitika yan si Uy ngayon lang binusisi? kasi talo ang pastor mong boy dila hahahaha

Local positions have less stringent eligibility checks in practice. The constitutional requirement for natural-born citizenship applies specifically to members of Congress. Kaya rin wala nangahas na mag file ng kaso dati nung councilor pa siya, because the public is not aware of his citizenship. At malaki ba ang kapalit kapag ipaglaban mo ang pagiging local councilor?

councilor nga namin yan at kapitbahay ko mismo yang si joey uy. masasabi kong napaka simpleng tao nyan mas malaki pa nga ang bahay ko sa bahay nyan eh kahit na matagal ng politiko yan, hindi mo makikitang katulad ni abante yan na naka mamahaling sasakyan at bullet proof pa lol.

Parang alam ko na itong script kung saan papatungo, pang PR sa public. Simpleng taong lang, pero kaya mag-afford ng international lawyer at 16 local lawyers to defend their crimes.

haha naging stray nga lang yan dahil sa disqualification, same lang din yan na naging winner lang dahil sa disqualification, hindi yan stray from the start, tingnan na lang natin ang result ng appeal since reversible pa yan, nothing is final yet

Let's wait na lang yung decision sa SC.

 

[-M I A Z H E R-]

Local positions have less stringent eligibility checks in practice. The constitutional requirement for natural-born citizenship applies specifically to members of Congress. Kaya rin wala nangahas na mag file ng kaso dati nung councilor pa siya, because the public is not aware of his citizenship. At malaki ba ang kapalit kapag ipaglaban mo ang pagiging local councilor?

Hahahahahaha ngayon na nanalo tsaka nag check?

Ama niya chinese - nanay nya pinay dito sya pinanganak at lumaki.

Naiproklama pero binawi, sana hindi nalang nag election hahahaha

ngayon makakaupo na yung isang NPA na Partylist hahahaha hayop na Garcia

 

[BicycleHorse]

Ama niya chinese - nanay nya pinay dito sya pinanganak at lumaki.

Alam mo naman pala Chinise ang ama niya at 5 years after siya pinanganak ay saka lang na naturalized.

ngayon makakaupo na yung isang NPA na Partylist hahahaha hayop na Garcia

Another not sure statement mo naman porket natalo yung pambato ng walang kwentang VP.

 

[HowSoonIsNow]

Parang alam ko na itong script kung saan papatungo, pang PR sa public. Simpleng taong lang, pero kaya mag-afford ng international lawyer at 16 local lawyers to defend their crimes.

basahin mo ng hindi ka mag mukhang bugok na itlog

No Replacement by Second Placer:• Philippine jurisprudence clarifies that if a candidate's certificate of candidacy (COC) is void ab initio (from the beginning) due to disqualification, even if they win the election, their votes are considered stray votes.• Therefore, the candidate who received the second highest number of votes does not automatically replace the disqualified winner.
Dominador Jalosjos vs. COMELEC (G.R. No. 193237, June 26, 2012) – The Supreme Court said the second placer cannot be proclaimed because it would go against the principle of majority rule.
isa pa, ang protesta ni abante laban doon kay joey uy ay hindi comelec ang dapat mag hatol kung sya nga ba ay natural born citizen or hindi. dahil hindi naman husgado ang comelec. husgado lang ang makakapag sabi kung sya ba ay dapat na ma disqualify or hindi.

 

[-M I A Z H E R-]

Alam mo naman pala Chinise ang ama niya at 5 years after siya pinanganak ay saka lang na naturalized.

hahahahahaha kailan pinanganak at saan?

Another not sure statement mo naman porket natalo yung pambato ng walang kwentang VP.

outdated, mag update² ka nman ng OS mo hahahaha mkakaupo na ang NPA na partylist

basahin mo ng hindi ka mag mukhang bugok na itlog

No Replacement by Second Placer:• Philippine jurisprudence clarifies that if a candidate's certificate of candidacy (COC) is void ab initio (from the beginning) due to disqualification, even if they win the election, their votes are considered stray votes.• Therefore, the candidate who received the second highest number of votes does not automatically replace the disqualified winner.
Dominador Jalosjos vs. COMELEC (G.R. No. 193237, June 26, 2012) – The Supreme Court said the second placer cannot be proclaimed because it would go against the principle of majority rule.
isa pa, ang protesta ni abante laban doon kay joey uy ay hindi comelec ang dapat mag hatol kung sya nga ba ay natural born citizen or hindi. dahil hindi naman husgado ang comelec. husgado lang ang makakapag sabi kung sya ba ay dapat na ma disqualify or hindi.

Tagapagmana ng Simbahan ni Abante yan

 

[HowSoonIsNow]

hahahahahaha kailan pinanganak at saan?

pagkakaintindi nya sa binasa nya si joey uy ang naging naturalized citizen after 5 years na ipinanganak si joey uy. di ni naintindihan na yung tatay ni joey uy ang naging naturalized citizen. amb0b0 amputa kaumay kausap hahaha. nanay nya pinay at sa pilipinas sya ipinanganak baket sya gagawing naturalized citizen?

 

[BicycleHorse]

No Replacement by Second Placer:• Philippine jurisprudence clarifies that if a candidate's certificate of candidacy (COC) is void ab initio (from the beginning) due to disqualification, even if they win the election, their votes are considered stray votes.• Therefore, the candidate who received the second highest number of votes does not automatically replace the disqualified winner.
Dominador Jalosjos vs. COMELEC (G.R. No. 193237, June 26, 2012) – The Supreme Court said the second placer cannot be proclaimed because it would go against the principle of majority rule.

Tama ka, Abante Jr. is not considered a second placer in the context of the 2025 Manila 6th District congressional election. Since Joey Chua Uy’s certificate of candidacy (COC) was declared void ab initio by the Comelec Second Division due to his ineligibility (not being a natural-born Filipino citizen), all votes cast for Uy were considered stray votes. As a result, Uy’s candidacy was effectively nullified, and he was not a valid candidate.

Abante, as the only remaining qualified candidate with valid votes (63,358 votes compared to Uy’s now-stray 64,746 votes), was declared the winner by the Comelec on June 18, 2025.

hahahahahaha kailan pinanganak at saan?

pagkakaintindi nya sa binasa nya si joey uy ang naging naturalized citizen after 5 years na ipinanganak si joey uy. di ni naintindihan na yung tatay ni joey uy ang naging naturalized citizen.

Luis Joey Chua Uy is considered not a natural-born Filipino because he derived his citizenship from his father, Uy Ho, who was naturalized as a Filipino in 1967, five years after Uy’s birth in 1962. Under the 1935 Constitution, which governed citizenship at the time of Uy’s birth, legitimate children of foreign fathers (Uy’s father was Chinese at the time) could not automatically acquire natural-born Filipino status. Instead, Uy became a Filipino citizen through his father’s naturalization, making him a naturalized citizen, not natural-born, as defined by Article IV, Section 2 of the 1987 Constitution (citizens from birth without performing any act to acquire citizenship).

isa pa, ang protesta ni abante laban doon kay joey uy ay hindi comelec ang dapat mag hatol kung sya nga ba ay natural born citizen or hindi. dahil hindi naman husgado ang comelec. husgado lang ang makakapag sabi kung sya ba ay dapat na ma disqualify or hindi.

Mag research ka pa muna para maging valid yung argument mo.

 

[HowSoonIsNow]

Tama ka, Abante Jr. is not considered a second placer in the context of the 2025 Manila 6th District congressional election. Since Joey Chua Uy’s certificate of candidacy (COC) was declared void ab initio by the Comelec Second Division due to his ineligibility (not being a natural-born Filipino citizen), all votes cast for Uy were considered stray votes. As a result, Uy’s candidacy was effectively nullified, and he was not a valid candidate.

Abante, as the only remaining qualified candidate with valid votes (63,358 votes compared to Uy’s now-stray 64,746 votes), was declared the winner by the Comelec on June 18, 2025.

marunong ka naman sigurong mag basa at umunawa ng binabasa mo no? basahin mo ulit para di ka nagmumukhang mahina ang reading comprehension

No Replacement by Second Placer:• Philippine jurisprudence clarifies that if a candidate's certificate of candidacy (COC) is void ab initio (from the beginning) due to disqualification, even if they win the election, their votes are considered stray votes.• Therefore, the candidate who received the second highest number of votes does not automatically replace the disqualified winner.
Dominador Jalosjos vs. COMELEC (G.R. No. 193237, June 26, 2012) – The Supreme Court said the second placer cannot be proclaimed because it would go against the principle of majority rule.

Luis Joey Chua Uy is considered not a natural-born Filipino because he derived his citizenship from his father, Uy Ho, who was naturalized as a Filipino in 1967, five years after Uy’s birth in 1962. Under the 1935 Constitution, which governed citizenship at the time of Uy’s birth, legitimate children of foreign fathers (Uy’s father was Chinese at the time) could not automatically acquire natural-born Filipino status. Instead, Uy became a Filipino citizen through his father’s naturalization, making him a naturalized citizen, not natural-born, as defined by Article IV, Section 2 of the 1987 Constitution (citizens from birth without performing any act to acquire citizenship).

so kung baliktad, ang nanay nya ang chinese at ang tatay filipino? what then??

Mag research ka pa muna para maging valid yung argument mo.

saan ba isinasampa ang protest case? comelec ba or sa korte? b0b0 mo nman

 

[-M I A Z H E R-]

Luis Joey Chua Uy is considered not a natural-born Filipino because he derived his citizenship from his father, Uy Ho, who was naturalized as a Filipino in 1967, five years after Uy’s birth in 1962. Under the 1935 Constitution, which governed citizenship at the time of Uy’s birth, legitimate children of foreign fathers (Uy’s father was Chinese at the time) could not automatically acquire natural-born Filipino status. Instead, Uy became a Filipino citizen through his father’s naturalization, making him a naturalized citizen, not natural-born, as defined by Article IV, Section 2 of the 1987 Constitution (citizens from birth without performing any act to acquire citizenship).

Mabuti pa nga si Uy may biography hahahaha paano nalang si Joel Chua? congressman din ngayon intsik din yan hahaha idol mo din ba?

Hipokrito kalang hahahaha

 

[BicycleHorse]

marunong ka naman sigurong mag basa at umunawa ng binabasa mo no? basahin mo ulit para di ka nagmumukhang mahina ang reading comprehension

No Replacement by Second Placer:• Philippine jurisprudence clarifies that if a candidate's certificate of candidacy (COC) is void ab initio (from the beginning) due to disqualification, even if they win the election, their votes are considered stray votes.• Therefore, the candidate who received the second highest number of votes does not automatically replace the disqualified winner.
Dominador Jalosjos vs. COMELEC (G.R. No. 193237, June 26, 2012) – The Supreme Court said the second placer cannot be proclaimed because it would go against the principle of majority rule.

Tanong ko lang sa iyo dahil taga District 6 ka rin naman at kapit bahay mo pa siya. Mayroon pa ibang kandidato sa bukod sa kanilang dalawa sa pagka Congress?

so kung baliktad, ang nanay nya ang chinese at ang tatay filipino? what then??

If that's the case, he would derive his citizenship from his father and be considered a natural-born Filipino citizen under the 1935 Constitution, as he would be a citizen from birth without needing to perform any act to acquire or perfect his citizenship.

saan ba isinasampa ang protest case? comelec ba or sa korte? b0b0 mo nman

Look at yourself. Sino tinatawag mong b0b0? Sino ang tinatanungan mo?

 

[HowSoonIsNow]

Tanong ko lang sa iyo dahil taga District 6 ka rin naman at kapit bahay mo pa siya. Mayroon pa ibang kandidato sa bukod sa kanilang dalawa sa pagka Congress?

regardless kahit gaano pa kadami ng kandidato, there is no replacement by second placer. di mo gets??

If that's the case, he would derive his citizenship from his father and be considered a natural-born Filipino citizen under the 1935 Constitution, as he would be a citizen from birth without needing to perform any act to acquire or perfect his citizenship.

eto ang article from the 1935 constitution para di ka mangmang sa sinasabi mo.

ARTICLE IV​

CITIZENSHIP

Section 1. The following are citizens of the Philippines:

(1) Those who are citizens of the Philippine Islands at the time of the adoption of this Constitution.

(2) Those born in the Philippine Islands of foreign parents who, before the adoption of this Constitution, had been elected to public office in the Philippine Islands.

(3) Those whose fathers are citizens of the Philippines.

(4) Those whose mothers are citizens of the Philippines and, upon reaching the age of majority, elect Philippine citizenship.

(5) Those who are naturalized in accordance with law.

Section 2. Philippine citizenship may be lost or reacquired in the manner provided by law.

anong sinasabi dyan pag ang mother mo eh filipino??

 

[Lerold]

dami dami pagtangol si boy dila pa, sinuka na nga ng botante, saklap pa di taga dun

 

[BicycleHorse]

regardless kahit gaano pa kadami ng kandidato, there is no replacement by second placer. di mo gets??

Lol, tinatanong ko lang kita kung may other candidates pa sa pagka congress tapos pagalit ka pang sumagot. As far as I know, there are only 2 candidates who run for Congress in the 6th District of Manila. Naging stray vote yung mga boto ni Uy after Comelec voided his COC, which means Abante is the ONLY REMAINING QUALIFIED CANDIDATE with valid votes. Since there were no other candidates, Abante was not a "second placer" but the sole candidate with valid votes, making his proclamation as the winner consistent with the majority rule and the Comelec’s authority under Section 78 of the Omnibus Election Code.

ARTICLE IV​

CITIZENSHIP

Section 1. The following are citizens of the Philippines:

(3) Those whose fathers are citizens of the Philippines.

(4) Those whose mothers are citizens of the Philippines and, upon reaching the age of majority, elect Philippine citizenship.

ito basahin at unawain mo ng mabuti, baka hindi mo pa maunawaan at kaylangan ko pa sa iyo iexplain na pang elementary.

 

[plhbg1]

ito basahin at unawain mo ng mabuti, baka hindi mo pa maunawaan at kaylangan ko pa sa iyo iexplain na pang elementary.

haha binago na ang rules bossing as to who are the natural-born, wag na nating pag-usapan ang 1935 kasi superceded na yan ng 1987 constitution, let's pay attention to what 1987 constitution say, all who are filipino citizens (both natural born and naturalized) at the time of the adoption of this constitution are deemed natural born, so wala na dapat pagtalunan pa

Lol, tinatanong ko lang kita kung may other candidates pa sa pagka congress tapos pagalit ka pang sumagot. As far as I know, there are only 2 candidates who run for Congress in the 6th District of Manila. Naging stray vote yung mga boto ni Uy after Comelec voided his COC, which means Abante is the ONLY REMAINING QUALIFIED CANDIDATE with valid votes. Since there were no other candidates, Abante was not a "second placer" but the sole candidate with valid votes, making his proclamation as the winner consistent with the majority rule and the Comelec’s authority under Section 78 of the Omnibus Election Code.

wag na din natin pag usapan ang election code since meron nang interpretation ang supreme court on the mangudadatu vs comelec case, it said that the votes are only considered stray if the voters deliberately voted to a known disqualified candidate, so since after election na ang disqualification ni joey uy then obviously the votes are not stray since voters still think joey is qualified at the time of their voting, and since there is no stray votes then the second placer cannot be the winner

 

[-Just4Fun-]

Baka makatulong sayo to BicycleHorse

 

[BicycleHorse]

haha binago na ang rules bossing as to who are the natural-born, wag na nating pag-usapan ang 1935 kasi superceded na yan ng 1987 constitution, let's pay attention to what 1987 constitution say, all who are filipino citizens (both natural born and naturalized) at the time of the adoption of this constitution are deemed natural born, so wala na dapat pagtalunan pa

Hindi sinasabi ng 1987 Constitution na lahat ng citizen noong 1987 ay natural-born. Ang natural-born, yung citizen na mula pagkasilang nang hindi kailangang gumawa ng aksyon para maging Pilipino. Si Uy, naturalized, kaya hindi siya natural-born. Kahit 1987 Constitution ang basehan, disqualified pa rin siya.

wag na din natin pag usapan ang election code since meron nang interpretation ang supreme court on the mangudadatu vs comelec case, it said that the votes are only considered stray if the voters deliberately voted to a known disqualified candidate, so since after election na ang disqualification ni joey uy then obviously the votes are not stray since voters still think joey is qualified at the time of their voting, and since there is no stray votes then the second placer cannot be the winner

Walang ganyang ruling sa Mangudadatu v. COMELEC. Mahalaga ang COC at kapag void ang COC, tulad ni Uy na hindi natural-born, stray vote yan kahit kailan nadisqualify. Si Abante lang ang natirang valid na candidate, kaya siya ang nanalo, hindi second placer.

 

[plhbg1]

Hindi sinasabi ng 1987 Constitution na lahat ng citizen noong 1987 ay natural-born. Ang natural-born, yung citizen na mula pagkasilang nang hindi kailangang gumawa ng aksyon para maging Pilipino. Si Uy, naturalized, kaya hindi siya natural-born. Kahit 1987 Constitution ang basehan, disqualified pa rin siya.

haha saang constitution ba yan, halatang di mo binasa ang article 4 section 2 which quotes section 1

Walang ganyang ruling sa Mangudadatu v. COMELEC. Mahalaga ang COC at kapag void ang COC, tulad ni Uy na hindi natural-born, stray vote yan kahit kailan nadisqualify. Si Abante lang ang natirang valid na candidate, kaya siya ang nanalo, hindi second placer.

haha saang ruling ba yan, halatang di mo binasa ang page 23 of the 37-page decision paper of supreme court on the mangudadatu case

eto pa news article kahapon lang yan haha You do not have permission to view the full content of this post. Log in or register now.

 

[BicycleHorse]

haha saang constitution ba yan, halatang di mo binasa ang article 4 section 2 which quotes section 1

Binsa mo ba yung section 1(3)? You forgot to address the specific requirement of electing citizenship under Section 1(3)

haha saang ruling ba yan, halatang di mo binasa ang page 23 of the 37-page decision paper of supreme court on the mangudadatu case

eto pa news article kahapon lang yan haha You do not have permission to view the full content of this post. Log in or register now.

Balik ko sa iyo yung tanong, may iba pang candidate bukod kay Uy at Abante? Kung wala, then it's not valid because he is the only qualified candidate with valid cabdidate. Unless kung maglalagay ka ng ghost candidate, automatic nasa second place si Abante.