🔒 Closed Which is correct: "it is something that never changes" or "it is something which never changes"?

Status
Not open for further replies.

plhbg1

Captain Hot Lips
Both can be correct since “which” and “that” are used in British speech and writing as relative pronouns or relative determiners that introduce subordinate clauses (e.g., in this case, “which/that never changes”).

However, in American speech and writing, “which” is reserved for introducing non-restrictive subordinate clauses, while “that” is reserved for introducing restrictive subordinate clauses.

Examples:
  • “It is something that never changes, although it is not required for the functioning of the machine.” (Restrictive)
  • “It is something which, although it never changes, is not required for the functioning of the machine.” (Non-restrictive)
Note that a restrictive clause is necessary for the proper understanding of the sentence, while a non-restrictive clause is not.
The non-restrictive clause could be omitted from the sentence without changing its meaning, while the restrictive clause cannot be omitted without changing the sentence’s meaning.
 
Simplified answer:

The clause that comes after the word “which” or “that” is the determining factor in deciding which one to use.

*If the clause is essential to the meaning of the sentence, you use “that.”
*If you could drop the clause and leave the meaning of the sentence intact, use “which.”


The abovementioned example is an uncertain clause; therefore, both relative pronouns can be used.
 
The abovementioned example is an uncertain clause; therefore, both relative pronouns can be used.
actually we can use both to all clauses, it is the use of them that determines whether the clause is restrictive or not, so if we intend something to be restricted then we use "that"

you are correct about them being pronouns instead of conjunctions, edit ko na yung opening post, thanks
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

About this Thread

  • 4
    Replies
  • 646
    Views
  • 3
    Participants
Last reply from:
plhbg1

Trending Topics

Online now

Members online
442
Guests online
14,967
Total visitors
15,409

Forum statistics

Threads
2,361,667
Posts
29,411,755
Members
1,058,520
Latest member
heb
Back
Top