Nezukooooooooooooo
Uhmmm... I am confused, sinagot ko lang naman yung tanong mo?
Paano ko na-misunderstood? What did I miss?
You asked kung yung mga tambay pay some tax even though they're not working? And you said na 'di lahat ng Pilipino may ambag'.
Sumagot ako with a 'yes', in-explain ko kung 'paano' ba sila nakakaltasan ng tax through their purchases and services availed. In-explain ko kung paanong napunta sa kanila yung burden/responsibility nung tax though di sila yung nag-earn nung pera.
Sinama ko mga bata kasi kailangan sa expanation ko sa kasi nga sabi mo, 'di lahat ng pilipino' -- I thought then you're pertaining sa mga literal ni di kaya magbayad/makaltasan ng tax.
'Paano ba nakakaltasan ng tax ang 'lahat' ng mga pilipino but especially yung mga individuals that are not taxed through their salaries'. Those includes unemployed, students, babies.
-Unemployed, kasi wala nga silang trabaho.
-Students, kasi mostly are not in the legal age to work and yung pera nila came from their guardians as allowance.
-Babies, kasi, well, under pa sila ng parents nila and they do not have the capability to even buy anything, kasi baby nga sila.
Pero I admit, pangit yung analogy ko

mali pa yung wording, "responsibilidad mo na kung paano mo yun gagamitiin".
Sinagot ko yung tanong mo and statement:
- Di lahat ng Pilipino may ambag - yes may ambag sila through (products/services) tax (except babies)
- Yung mga tambay paanong may ambag sila kung wala silang tabaho - through products/services tax
_____________________________________________________________________________
Now dun sa morality nung nangyayari, well, it is what it is.
Though you are right, and I agree, sobrang unfair sa mga employed na may tax sa salaries nila, when yung ibang mga nakikinabang sa government programs (4PS), ginagamit nila sa sugal/bisyo yung pera na natatanggap nila. Lalo't higit dahil directly galing sa tax yung nakukuha nilang pera.
Again, that is the harsh reality, and we can't do anything about that (unless may mag ammend or mas higpitan yung batas)
But still, they are considered 'tax payers' dahil nga they buy things and they avail services, and that's where they are taxed.